This research paper investigates first generation (FG) upper level undergraduate engineering students’ engineering experiences and how their experiences affect feelings of engineering belongingness. When compared to “traditional” continuing generation (CG) students, FG students have been shown to have difficulty meeting admission requirements, a need for external employment, and obligations to family. This body of research illuminates FG struggle, but little literature focuses on FG students’ personal experiences and ways they are successful in attaining an engineering degree. This work strives to understand how FG engineering students develop belongingness to major, often at higher levels than their CG peers.
Five FG engineering students with high quantitative belongingness were selected for an interview. A semi-structured interview protocol based in interpretive phenomenological analysis was used to elucidate the students’ experiences that fostered belongingness. Separate themes from each student were created from coding and then overarching themes unified a shared experience.
The following overarching themes were prevalent among the participants: similarity to classmates, recognition as an engineer by peers, limited questioning of belongingness, and belongingness is a state of mind. The results depict that elements of engineering identity play a part in making students feel they belong (e.g., recognition), but in some cases, belongingness is distinct from identity constructs (e.g., being similar to others). Past literature has shown that belongingness and identity may be related, and created by each other, while findings in this study show that identity and belongingness are interrelated and give the research community further insight for upper level FG engineering students.
Hank Boone is a doctoral student at the University of Nevada, Las Vegas. He is pursuing a PhD in Educational Psychology. He is a graduate research assistant collecting data for the NSF grant funded project titled Cultivating Tomorrow’s Engineers through the Entertainment & Hospitality Landscape. Hank received his MS and BS degree in Mechanical Engineering from University of Nevada, Reno. Hank has professional experience serving as a college recruiter, advisor, and success coach. His research interests include sense of belonging, identity formation, and retention of first-generation college students. Hank is the first person in his family to receive a four-year college degree.
Adam Kirn is an Associate Professor of Engineering Education at the University of Nevada, Reno.
Are you a researcher? Would you like to cite this paper? Visit the ASEE document repository at peer.asee.org for more tools and easy citations.
